The Biggest Overseeding Mistake Homeowners Make (And How to Avoid It)

Mar 10, 2025

When it comes to choosing the right seed for your lawn, understanding the difference between annual and perennial seeds is crucial. Many people don't realize that not all grass seed is created equal, especially when shopping at big box stores where sales and promotions can be tempting. One common misconception is that you're getting a better deal with the seed labeled "annual," but in reality, this can lead to frustrating results in the long term.

What’s the Difference Between Annual and Perennial Seeds?

  • Annual Seeds: As the name suggests, annual seeds only last for one growing season. They are quick to germinate, but come fall or winter, they die off, leaving you with bare patches in your lawn. This means that every year, you'll need to reseed your lawn if you want to maintain a lush, green yard. While these seeds are often inexpensive and go on sale frequently, they are not the best long-term investment.

  • Perennial Seeds: Perennial seeds, on the other hand, grow back year after year. Once planted, they develop a strong root system and will continue to thrive through multiple seasons. The seedlings that emerge from perennial seeds will also be perennial, so you won’t need to reseed your lawn annually. The initial investment may be higher than buying annual seed, but in the long run, it’s far more economical and sustainable.

Why Perennial Seeds Are the Better Investment

When you're investing in your lawn, overseeding can be an expensive process. However, the value of a healthy, year-round lawn far outweighs the initial cost. If you're overseeding with annual seed, you'll likely find that your hard work and investment go to waste after a single season.

In contrast, investing in perennial seeds ensures that your lawn remains vibrant and lush over time, providing you with a consistent and healthy lawn season after season.

How to Identify the Seed You’re Buying

If you’re ever uncertain about the type of seed you’re purchasing, simply read the label on the bag. If it doesn’t specify whether the seed is annual or perennial, you can safely assume that it’s annual. To make sure you’re purchasing quality perennial seed, visit local garden centers or specialty chemical suppliers that offer a range of seeds, and make sure you’re getting the right seed for your lawn.

Investing in the right seed now can save you from the frustration of dealing with patchy, unhealthy grass in the future. The next time you're choosing seed, remember: annual seeds are a short-term fix, while perennial seeds provide lasting results.

If you’re looking for professional help with overseeding or selecting the right seed for your lawn, contact us today to learn more!